The komi for 9x9 Go forum

4 replies. Last post: 2015-12-01

Reply to this topic Return to forum

The komi for 9x9
  • mmKALLL ★ at 2015-10-10

    Hey,
    I’m starting to get a bit bothered by the lower komi for 9x9, even though black’s advantage is undeniably much stronger on the small board. The counter-argument is that there are less points on the smaller board, so each komi point also has a far larger impact on the game. However, most high-dan players advocate 6.5, if not 7 or even 7.5 points of komi for the 9x9. Since games tend to be much more even than on 19x19, the difference of single points in tactical decision-making is noticeable on 9x9 even in kyu-level games.
    Therefore, I’d like to propose raising the komi for 9x9 to either 6.5 or 7 points. GoQuest, a recently popular service for fast 9x9 games, uses 7.

  • Sighris at 2015-11-23

    ah, interesting.... I wish I had read this (above) before I replied to your post in the other thread ( “Komi pie, lengthening the title?” )... so I would guess you would recommend the same komi (6.5 or 7.0) for 13x13 games too; is that correct mmKALLL ?  Does anybody else have any thoughts or opinions on this? 

  • mmKALLL ★ at 2015-11-25

    I guess 6.5 would be alright for 13x13 (most likely better than 5.5), but I believe that to be the least analyzed board size of the three standard ones.

  • Sighris at 2015-12-01

    IDK, but if a komi of 7 is fair for both 9x9 and 19x19, I would guess it is also fair for 13x13. {“fair” meaning it results in equal number of wins for both Black and White in large data-sets of equal skilled players} 

Return to forum

Reply to this topic




Include game board: [game;id:123456] or [game;id:123456;move:20] or [game;id:123456;move:20;title:some text]