I was wondering if anyone would like to talk about their experience learning new abstract board games via PBeM etc. I find it very hard to learn a game without playing it dozens of times in a short period -- so learning to play a board game on LG is hard for me. Has anyone had a better experience? Have you become strong in a particular game that you've only ever played online?
Hi, my experience is quite the opposite. Although I'm by no means an expert player of Connect6, I feel that I've gained more experience and insights from playing slow-paces games on LG than playing blitz games on other real-time gaming sites. Without much time pressure, I can afford to think more deeply on LG.
I think LG is excellent when you already play the game well enough, but for starting from scratch it is too slow. Fortunately, you can download some free playing software for pretty much every game or find a flash implementation to play online. Playing against a computer helps understand the game and is a fast way, even if it may teach bad habits in the long term. Also, some bots are really strong (or I may be really stupid) but I never managed to win a game against the Reversi program that comes with Debian and have never tried to play humans since I feel I must be really bad. Anyway, trying to play one game passably (go in my case) is a big enough effort for me.
My approach when starting to play a new game on a turn-based server is to dedicate a few hours to first play through a few games of strong players vs weaker players, to see how the strong players win, then play through a few games between strong players, and try to understand some of their moves. I'll also usually selfplay a game or two before actually taking on a human opponent on a turn-based server.
Of course, it does help that most of the games which I play are chess and checkers variant, which tend to share strategical and tactical motifs with each other. Still, before I commit to a match in a new game which might last weeks or months, I think spending a few hours in preparation is prudent.
I've found that the two games that I play on LG that I had never played before (Amazons and Connect 6) are two of my weakest games. I learned Go, Lines Of Action, and Go Moku at another turn-based site where I played hundreds of games against weaker opposition. It took me several years to get good at those games playing on a turn-based site. It might be quicker against better opponents since you will get an idea of proper strategy.
Most games I play here, I only tried here. I think it depends a lot on the game. In games like chess, many people have played it a lot in real life and are really good so the competition here is really tough. On the other hand, in games like minishogi I think most people are new to the game, so getting into the game just by playing here is easily possible.
I had played a little Chess and Hex before joining Little Golem, but all the other games were new to me. I think I have learnt a lot in many of these games. I think that playing many matches rather fast is a good start. Then, asking someone who is good at the game to play a "teaching game" is a good idea to improve further. In Dots and Boxes, reading wccanards papers is also very useful. For Chess and GO, I expect that reading can help you a LOT, but I've never done so myself, and thus I'm not very good in these games either.